
Surgeon Calls for Criminal Investigation Into Deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary
Representative photo ยท Photo: Bill Harrison / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0
A senior surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary has called for a police inquiry after an internal report linked 19 patient deaths to avoidable surgical complications.
A senior consultant at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, Dr. Mohammed Habib, has formally called for a criminal investigation into alleged corporate homicide following the deaths of at least 19 patients. The surgeon, who has repeatedly raised concerns since 2021 regarding the hospital's liver and pancreatic surgery departments, believes that dozens of patients may have died unnecessarily due to systemic failures. While many people might search for a Call Scottish hospital investigation to understand the scope of these events, the situation at the facility has become a focal point of intense scrutiny in the Scottish Parliament.
Dr. Habibโs allegations were supported by an internal report commissioned by NHS Grampian, the health board responsible for the hospital. The report, which was published by solicitor Aamer Anwar, confirmed that 19 patients died due to serious adverse events between 2015 and 2021. External experts from the universities of Edinburgh and Leeds noted that the death rate in the affected surgical units reached as high as 18% between 2017 and 2020, significantly higher than the national average of 2-3%.
A surgeon is calling for a criminal investigation into 19 avoidable patient deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
During a session at Holyrood, First Minister John Swinney described the disclosures as being of the gravest concern. However, he rejected calls from Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra for an immediate criminal investigation, arguing that the governmentโs current strategy of demanding leadership changes and urgent reforms at the health board is the appropriate path forward. The liver and pancreatic surgery unit was eventually closed in March 2026 after an external expert labeled the persistent high mortality rate a red-flag indicator of systemic failure.
NHS Grampian Chief Executive Laura Skaife-Knight stated that the board is aware of the allegations and that a thorough investigation has already taken place. She added that any new evidence will be carefully considered through the appropriate clinical and legal processes. Meanwhile, a recent report by the NHS watchdog, Healthcare Improvement Scotland, highlighted serious shortcomings regarding the boardโs leadership, specifically noting a failure to be transparent in its accounts.
Why it matters This situation represents a significant crisis in medical governance, impacting patient safety standards and public trust in the Scottish healthcare system. The ongoing scrutiny of NHS Grampian highlights the critical importance of whistleblowing protections and the need for rapid administrative responses when clinical mortality rates deviate sharply from national benchmarks.
Sources
More like this

Todd Blanche's wife Kristine promoted unproven health treatments online

UK Vulnerable to Covid Due to Border and Test Failures

Meta Removes Anti-Vaccine Posts Following Report on CHD

