
Tether invokes The Big Short in swipe at S&P over USDT reserve risks
Representative photo ยท Photo: Josh B / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0
S&P Global has kept Tether at the lowest stability score as riskier assets form a larger share of reserves, prompting a sharp response from the firm.
This is news, not investment advice. NexVani Media is not a SEBI-registered investment adviser and does not recommend buying or selling any security. Do your own research or consult a registered adviser before investing.
S&P Global Ratings has maintained Tetherโs USDt at the lowest possible level on its stablecoin stability scale. The rating agency pointed to a growing share of riskier assets taking up space within the tokenโs reserves. In a report published on November 18, S&P scored the ability of USDt to maintain its dollar peg at 5, which denotes a weak standing. This assessment remains unchanged from November 2025. According to S&P, higher-risk holdings such as gold, Bitcoin, public equities, secured loans, and corporate bonds totaled 28% of USDt in circulation as of September 30, increasing from 24% in the previous year. The rating agency warned that a significant decline in the value of these assets could leave USDT undercollateralized. In response to the assessment, Tether pushed back against the methodology. The company told Cointelegraph that the issue lies with S&P's framework rather than its reserves, drawing a parallel to the financial crisis film The Big Short to highlight flaws in traditional financial evaluation. Tether argued that its own figures demonstrate solid backing, referencing a September 30 reserve report attested by BDO. That report listed approximately $191.5 billion in assets against $183.5 billion in liabilities, resulting in roughly $7.95 billion in excess assets. S&P acknowledged finding additional weaknesses, including regulatory oversight in El Salvador where Tether relocated in January 2025, but noted it made no further downward adjustments because the scale cannot drop below 5.
Regulatory concerns and auditing transparency
The report highlighted that the National Commission of Digital Assets of El Salvador requires 70% of reserves to be held in assets liquidatable within 30 days. Tether defended this framework as broad enough to permit high-risk assets like gold and Bitcoin. S&P also noted the absence of a requirement to segregate reserve assets, contrasting with rules expected in the US and Europe, which leaves a lack of visibility regarding how assets are insulated from corporate risks. Meanwhile, KPMG issued an unqualified opinion on Tetherโs 2025 accounts in August 2026. However, S&P stated that these audited statements remain unpublished, limiting its ability to verify underlying information. S&P additionally pointed out that reserve reports do not name custodians and counterparties, and attestations continue on a quarterly basis rather than monthly.
S&P Global keeps Tether at a stability score of 5 as riskier reserve assets grow.
Why it matters
S&P Global made no downward adjustment in its latest Stablecoin Stability Assessment because 5 is the lowest available score on its scale. This ongoing rating reflects persistent concerns among traditional financial institutions regarding transparency, asset segregation, and the inclusion of volatile holdings in stablecoin backing.
Sources
More like this

Ledger Confirms Tampered Bitcoin Wallets in Berlin as Investigation Expands

Coinbase AI Blocks Millions in Scam, But a Simple Lie Exposes Vulnerability

Government Tests Reveal Chatgpt Claude Gemini and Grok Aided Attack Plans

