
Lawyer for Lucy Letby calls for urgent review of convictions after expert revelations
Representative photo ยท Photo: Anthony O'Neil / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0
Lucy Letby's legal team is demanding a review of her convictions following reports that a key prosecution medical witness was barred from clinical practice during her trial.
The legal representative for Lucy Letby, Mark McDonald, has formally requested that the court of appeal urgently review her convictions. This development follows recent revelations that Prof Peter Hindmarsh, a primary expert witness for the prosecution, was excluded from clinical practice in March 2023 due to safety concerns regarding his treatment of children. As a lawyer for Lucy Letby, McDonald argues that the failure to disclose this critical information to the defence raises fundamental questions about the safety of the trial's outcome.
During the trial, the prosecution described Hindmarsh as the pre-eminent expert in the field of insulin. His testimony, which suggested that two babies had been poisoned with insulin, was central to the case that resulted in Letby being found guilty of attempted murder. Letby was ultimately convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others, receiving 15 whole-life sentences.
Failure to disclose a key expert's clinical suspension raises fundamental questions about the safety of Letby's convictions.
Expert witness controversy
Internal documents revealed that while the trial was ongoing at Manchester Crown Court, Hindmarshโs employer, University College London Hospitals (UCLH), determined he posed a risk to child patients. In March 2023, a medical director at the trust wrote to the General Medical Council (GMC) stating that the hospital could not allow him to practice, even under supervision. Although the GMC investigated these concerns, the jury was never informed of the restriction or the underlying safety issues.
Letbyโs defence team confirmed they were not notified of these developments, and the Crown Prosecution Service has acknowledged it was not informed either. According to criminal procedure rules, experts are required to disclose any information that could undermine their credibility or impartiality. Legal experts noted that a failure to provide such disclosure, particularly when it impacts central evidence, may constitute grounds for an appeal. Since the original verdict, numerous medical and scientific experts have submitted reports to the Criminal Cases Review Commission, challenging the prosecutionโs medical case.
Why it matters
The non-disclosure of an expert witness's professional limitations strikes at the heart of judicial integrity. This case highlights the necessity of transparent evidence handling to prevent potential miscarriages of justice, a standard established following historical cases where flawed medical testimony led to wrongful convictions.
Sources
More like this
Mosque Set on Fire in Northern Israel as Politicians Blame Incitement

Two Dutch girls and family seek asylum in Kampen church

Eight Injured After Car Rams Palestinian Residents in Israeli City

