
Expert witness in Doctor Lucy Letby case was barred from practice during trial
Representative photo ยท Photo: David Hillas / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0
A key expert witness in the trial of Lucy Letby was barred from treating patients due to safety concerns, a fact never disclosed to the jury.
A senior medical professional who provided pivotal evidence in the trial of Doctor Lucy Letby was excluded from clinical practice by his employer during the legal proceedings, according to a recent investigation. Professor Peter Hindmarsh, a specialist in pediatric hormones, was described by prosecutors as a pre-eminent expert on insulin. However, it has emerged that the University College London Hospitals trust (UCLH) barred him from treating patients in March 2023, five months before the trial concluded.
The jury was never informed of this development, nor were they told that Hindmarshโs contract at Great Ormond Street Hospital had been terminated months prior to his testimony. The prosecution relied heavily on Hindmarshโs assertions that two babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital were poisoned with insulin, likely via intravenous fluid bags. These specific charges were among the first to result in guilty verdicts.
A key expert witness in the Doctor Lucy Letby case was barred from clinical practice during the trial.
Concerns over patient safety
UCLHโs decision to exclude Hindmarsh stemmed from concerns that his advice regarding insulin was not safe. The hospitalโs medical director informed the General Medical Council (GMC) that the trust could not accept the level of risk the professor appeared to pose to children. While the GMC sought to suspend his registration, an independent medical practitioners tribunal opted for direct supervision instead. This ruling had no practical effect, as the hospital had already barred him from practice entirely.
Although the Crown Prosecution Service informed Letbyโs legal team in February 2023 that Hindmarsh was under a GMC investigation, the defense was not notified of his subsequent exclusion from practice on safety grounds. Legal experts note that failures of disclosure can be grounds for a Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) referral. Letby, who maintains her innocence, has seen her appeal applications rejected, though her legal team continues to challenge the convictions.
Since the trial, numerous international medical experts have contested Hindmarshโs findings, arguing that his calculations were inaccurate and that the evidence of insulin poisoning was flawed. Despite these challenges, official inquiries have proceeded based on the original guilty verdicts.
Why it matters
The lack of transparency regarding an expert witnessโs professional status raises significant questions about the integrity of the trial process. If the defense had known of the safety concerns and the hospital's decision to bar Hindmarsh, they might have challenged his credibility as an expert witness. This revelation affects the ongoing efforts to review the case and highlights the critical importance of full disclosure in legal proceedings involving expert testimony.
Sources
More like this

Gun control advocate faces recovery after Washington DC mass shooting

Widow seeks answers after husband exposed to toxic lagoon fire dies of cancer

Yvette Cooper Announces New Health Support for Vulnerable People in England

