Exterior view of a New South Wales court building where an inquest into home birth infant deaths is taking place.
Health

Byron Bay Doula Inquest Hears Conflicting Accounts After Newborn Death

Representative photo ยท Photo: Andrea Schaffer from Sydney, Australia / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

By: NexVani DeskDate: 18 November 2026Views: 0

A New South Wales coroner's court has heard conflicting accounts over the death of a newborn following an unattended home birth involving a doula near Byron Bay.

A New South Wales coroner's court in Lismore is examining the circumstances surrounding the death of an infant known as Baby DH, who died following a home birth near Byron Bay, New South Wales. The proceedings are part of an ongoing inquest into the fatalities of four babies delivered during home births or free births across the state's northern rivers region between 2022 and 2024.

Baby DH was delivered in an inflatable pool in a candle-lit room at his parents' residence in Byron Bay, Australia, with no medically trained professionals present. According to evidence presented in court, signs that something was seriously wrong emerged within the first minutes of the baby's life. The parents repeatedly raised concerns with their doula, Amy Lou Smith, whom they had hired to assist them.

Home Birth Inquest in Byron Bay NSW

The court heard sharply differing accounts of what occurred after the birth. The father stated that the newborn appeared floppy, had a purple body with darker extremities, struggled to breathe, and had a low body temperature of 34.5 degrees Celsius. The parents testified that Smith offered assurances, suggested the baby's labored breathing was normal sounds, and noted an ambulance was only called just before the child stopped breathing.

In contrast, Smith testified that she never noticed the infant's body being purple, denied calling his breathing "cute little noises," and maintained that she did not provide clinical advice. She stated she believed the parents would have dialed an ambulance rather than texting an untrained doula if they had serious concerns.

A coronial inquest is investigating the deaths of four infants following home births in northern New South Wales.

The court heard Smith subsequently left the residence to manage a jumping castle for her son's birthday, later sending the parents a photograph of it while they were attempting to consult a general practitioner. Smith told the court the castle was already erected and that the parents were content with her departure. When the parents finally reached a doctor, they were advised to immediately contact emergency services. They performed CPR until paramedics arrived, but Baby DH was pronounced dead at the hospital. Smith sent infant CPR guidance and suggested calling an ambulance after the father had already placed the emergency call.

Evidence from neonatologist Dr. Paul Evans indicated that Baby DH had a complex congenital heart defect that could have been diagnosed via X-ray and managed if delivered near specialized hospital care. The court heard the parents had paid for Smith to take an online sovereign birth course after another birth attendant declined to help. Smith, who has a fine arts degree and a background in social and youth work, qualified as a doula in 2020.

Why it matters

The inquest scrutinizes the boundaries and responsibilities of non-medically qualified birth attendants during unattended home deliveries. By examining whether critical medical conditions went unaddressed due to non-clinical reassurances, the findings highlight the significant risks that arise when emergency interventions and specialist medical care are delayed during infant deliveries.

Add NexVani Media as a preferred source on Google

Sources

ND

NexVani Desk

NexVani Media brings you the most important world news as it happens, with every story linked to its sources.