A portrait of paediatrician Hilary Cass in the House of Lords.
Health

Expert behind NHS gender review withdraws support for conversion practices bill

Illustration: NexVani Media

By: NexVani DeskDate: 17 November 2026Views: 0

Paediatrician Hilary Cass warns that proposed legislation to ban conversion practices could harm healthcare professionals and parents.

Hilary Cass, the paediatrician who led a major review into NHS gender services, has announced she can no longer support the government's proposed legislation to ban conversion practices. While she is a recognized NHS expert in this field, she now argues that the draft bill is causing a chilling effect on medical professionals and could inadvertently place parents at risk.

The bill, which was published in June and is currently under parliamentary scrutiny, aims to outlaw practices intended to change an individual's sexual orientation or gender identity in England and Wales. Under the current proposals, those found guilty of such abuse could face an unlimited fine or up to five years in prison. While the government maintains that there is a high threshold for criminality, intending to target only acts that cause real harm, the legislation has faced significant opposition from religious leaders and rights advocates.

Concerns from an NHS expert

Cass, who now serves in the House of Lords, initially expressed support for the bill during the summer, noting that it provided clearer definitions regarding conversion practices. However, after providing evidence to a joint committee of MPs and peers this week, she confirmed that her stance has shifted. She stated that the bill as currently drafted is problematic and would require radical changes to be considered workable, though she expressed doubt that such changes are possible.

Hilary Cass warns the proposed conversion practices bill creates a chilling effect on healthcare professionals.

According to Cass, healthcare professionals are increasingly fearful of potential repercussions, including complaints and investigations, even when they perform ethical and appropriate therapy. She emphasized that because standards in this area are highly contested, clinicians are worried about the risk of prosecution, noting that the process of being investigated can itself act as an unwarranted punishment.

Conversely, other voices in the medical community remain in favor of the legislation. Dr. Igi Moon, representing a coalition of over 25 health and psychotherapy organizations, recently testified in support of the bill, stating that these groups are united in their desire for a legal ban. In response to the growing debate, a government spokesperson stated that they are taking all committee evidence seriously as they work to refine the legislation.

Why it matters

The proposed legislation represents a significant shift in how the state regulates therapeutic practices related to gender identity and sexual orientation. The concerns raised by Hilary Cass highlight the tension between protecting individuals from abuse and ensuring that medical professionals can continue to provide care without the constant threat of litigation. This debate affects the future of clinical standards for gender-related care and the legal rights of parents and practitioners in England and Wales.

Add NexVani Media as a preferred source on Google

Sources

ND

NexVani Desk

NexVani Media brings you the most important world news as it happens, with every story linked to its sources.